Violent Rapist Andrew Malkinson, How Undated Circumstantial DNA Won’t Prove His ‘Innocence’ & Why Deluded Emily Dugan Won’t Address What Happened To The Clothes & Footwear He Wore When He Worked As A Security Guard At The Ellesmere Shopping Centre (Part 9)

On the 27th January 2023 Emily Dugan wrote an article for the Guardian on violent rapist, parasitic predator and convicted fraudster (Thailand 2001) Andrew Malkinson.

Excerpts from Emily’s article on the violent rapist read as follows:

He was serving a life sentence for the rape of a 33-year-old woman left for dead on a Salford motorway embankment in 2003.

There was never any DNA linking him to the crime, but his insistence of his innocence only trapped him in prison for longer.

Arriving on Wednesday at the east London office of the law practice Appeal, which has been fighting his case, Malkinson was greeted with hugs of celebration.

He could hardly believe what was happening.

“I dreamed that they would find DNA evidence,”

he said.

“I hoped something would turn up that would prove I was telling the truth.

But this is almost beyond my expectations.”

I first met Malkinson in a grey, windswept car park outside HMP North Sea Camp in Lincolnshire.

It was December 2020 and his first taste of freedom.

He hugged his mum, Tricia, tight, whispering:

“It’s all over now.”

By Emily Dugan for the Guardian here dated 27th January 2023

Emily Dugan is deluded.

Andrew Malkinson did not whisper to his mother “It’s all over now”.

He can be heard quite clearly saying “It’s all over now” during the podcast Emily Dugan narrated and helped write back in 2021.

Emily Dugan then went on in her article to refer to Andrew Malkinson and his continued “torment” and included statements he had made earlier in January 2023;

“I feel like there’s a huge hole in my life

he said this week.

I got quite depressed over Christmastime

It slowly crept up on me, I fell into a darker and darker spiral, and it was horrible.

It was just a feeling of mourning for the loss of what’s gone

It’s like you’ve lost somebody but it’s a part of yourself

Andrew Malkinson – January 2023

Adoption & “It’s like you’ve lost somebody but it’s a part of yourself

Who and what exactly was Andrew Malkinson referring to?

In January 1987 Andrew Strugnell, as he was known then, and his then partner had a son.

Not long after his son had been born, Andrew Strugnell, who was 21 years old at the time, learned he had been adopted.

Up until this point Andrew Strugnell had always believed his father Phil Strugnell, who kicked him out of the family home when he was 17 years old, was his biological father.

Excerpts from a book written by Bob Woffinden and published in 2016 read as follows;

In 1983 he had to leave home.

Phil threw him out after an argument about the amount of rent that he was paying.

Bob Woffinden from his book The Nicholas Cases published in 2016

Bob Woffinden also referred to Andrew Malkinson’s adoption as follows;

He was working at a duck-processing factory, Cherry Valley Farms, when he met Jacqui Tyler.

She liked Bob Dylan and Genesis and was seven years older than him, and they struck up a relationship.

She had a mortgage on a small terraced house in central Grimsby where he moved in with her.

In 1986, they went to Amsterdam together and, shortly afterwards, Jacqui announced that she was pregnant.

The following year she gave birth to Andrew junior: little Andy.

The Amsterdam trip had given Andrew and Jacqui the travel bug.

They talked of starting a new life together in Australia.

Their plan was to go there for several months to find out if they liked it and finance their stay by taking short-term jobs.

In order to do that, they needed work permits.

Andrew applied and was asked to produce his birth certificate.

He didn’t have one so he went to the local register office.

That was how he discovered he wasn’t on the official register of births.

The assistant did some searching and soon realised the reason for the omission: he was on a subsidiary list – because he was adopted.

This came as a complete shock to him.

Naturally, he asked for his real parents’ names, but the assistant said she could not divulge them.

So he confronted his mother.

“I was pretty confused about all the secrecy”

he said,

“and a little angry”

The ’60s was the decade of the sexual revolution, but in 1966 it had yet to reach Grimsby.

So, at the time, this was a small family scandal.

Trisha was pregnant but unmarried

Happily, his mother found a new partner in Phil; but in order to satisfy the bureaucratic niceties of the time, he could only adopt Andrew if his partner did too.

So, bizarrely, Trisha became Andrew’s adoptive mother as well as his natural mother.

Bob Woffinden from his book The Nicholas Cases published in 2016

“I feel like there’s a huge hole in my life

In 1990, aged 24, Andrew Strugnell changed his and his sons surname by deed poll to Malkinson.

Not long after this Andrew Malkinson abandoned his son, similar to how his own biological father Paul Malkinson had done to him twenty four years earlier.

Andrew Malkinson told Emily Dugan in 2021 the reason he abandoned his son was because he was “drinking a lot more than” he “should have” and that he “couldn’t really handle it anymore” because apparently he “didn’t have the strength”.

Was violent rapist Andrew Malkinson referring to his son or his adoptive and biological fathers when he made the statement “I feel like there’s a huge hole in my life“?

An excerpt from an article headed “When Adults Discover They Were Adopted: The Ultimate Betrayal/Life Hi-Jacked” reads;

Initial feelings are often shock, disorientation and anger.

Often righteous indignation and feelings of betrayal are wide spread when one learns that all their “relatives” knew but them.

All had conspired in keeping the secret.

It‘s life shattering and most of all shatters the ability to trust.

Why did everyone know and keep it from me? 

Tap on the button below to read the full article:

Link to Part 10 here