Killer Karen Read: Why Did The Malignant Narcissist Text Laura Sullivan & Lie To Her & Yet Ignored John O’Keefe’s Friend Karl Dugal?

TIMELINE EXCERPTS

**Friday 31st DECEMBER 2021**

During a trip to Aruba, said to be with approximately 60 friends & family members, John O’Keefe bumped into his friend Marietta Sullivan in the lobby of the hotel he was staying in with Karen Read & his niece & nephew. Marirtta is the younger sister of Laura Sullivan. Laura had dated John’s friend & former partner Pat Rogers. Pat died by suicide on 19th November 2013. Marietta gave John a hug & asked him where he was going. Marietta then heard Karen yell “Who the fuck was that” & also heard John say “that’s Laura’s sister” Karen then said “I don’t give a fuck” then yelled to Marietta “fuck you” Karen went on to accuse John of having a fling with Marietta. Below is a screenshot of text messages sent from Karen Read to Aidan #Turtleboy (TB) Kearney, via an “intermediary” called Natalie Berschneider-Wiweke, regarding Laura Sullivan, Marietta Sullivan’s sister;

**SUNDAY 23rd JANUARY 2022**

Part of a statement made by John O’Keefe’s friend Karl Dugal below;

11:54am – Karen Read texted Brian Higgins “John died

12:00pm (Approx) – After leaving the Good Samaritan hospital in Brockton Karen Read called Paul O’Keefe during “the worst driving conditions” he had ever experienced, asking if she could come over “to see the kids”. Trooper Michael Proctor stated “And the fact that leaving Brockton, instead of going to Dighton, she back tracked to go to Canton to retrieve her vehicle, then go, double back to go to Dighton, which I found odd

12:30pm (Approx) – Karen Read arrived at 1 Meadows avenue with her father William (Bill) Read, followed by her brother Nathan Read & Nathan’s wife Kaitlin Boudreau Read

12:35pm (Approx) – Ring camera caught Karen Read’s brother Nathan Read, getting out of a car, then cleaning snow off of his & his sisters vehicles. But Nathan only cleaned the snow off of the left rear taillight of his sisters SUV

12:40pm (Approx) – Ring camera captured John O’Keefe’s nephew being dropped off by his friends parent

12:45pm – John O’Keefe’s friend Laura Sullivan, sister of Marietta Sullivan, messaged Karen Read “Karen it’s Laura please call me”

12:49pm – Trooper Proctor called Jennifer McCabe

12:50pm – Karen Read’s sister-in-law Kaitlin, was caught on Ring camera inspecting Karen’s damaged right rear taillight

1:00pm (Approx) – Troopers Michael Procter & Yuriy Bukhenik drove to the Good Samaritan hospital in Brockton

1:00pm (Approx) – Karen Read left 1 Meadows avenue, seemingly with her brother Nathan driving her SUV(?) Karen then drove to Dighton to her parents house with her father William Read during the “terrible blizzard”

1:07:20pm – Karen Read replied to Laura Sullivan “Hi Laura”

1:07:27pm – Karen Read texted Laura Sullivan “John passed away”

1:07:44pm – Karen Read texted Laura Sullivan & made a freudian slip stating “We found him in the snow at 5am” (Listen to Laura here)

1:07:43pm – Laura Sullivan texted Karen Read “Karen I’m shaking I’m so sorry”

1:07:52pm – Laura Sullivan texted Karen Read “I can’t stop crying”

1:07:56pm – Karen Read texted Laura Sullivan “Thank you

1:07:58pm – Laura Sullivan texted Karen Read “Why was he out there”

1:08:22pm – Karen Read texted Laura Sullivan “He left a party we were at. I don’t know what time. I didn’t even go in. I went to bed”

1:08:42pm – Laura Sullivan texted Karen Read “Oh my god”

1:09:20pm – Laura Sullivan texted Karen Read “Karen my heart breaks for everyone”

1:36:33pm – Erin O’Keefe called Karen Read who alleged she was with her father driving to Dighton (Exhibit 632) Karen had Erin on loudspeaker & Erin apparently asked “what the hell happened last night” Karen replied that her & John O’Keefe “were out, that she dropped him at a party afterwards, didn’t feel like going & went back to Canton” Karen told Erin she woke up at around 4:30am & couldn’t find John. She said she then woke Kayley to see if Kayley had heard from him. Karen also told Erin she “went to go out & look but the roads were bad, so went back & called Kerry & Jen so that they could drive together”. Erin also recalled Karen saying “she had to remember the bad times” which stuck Erin as “an odd comment to say” Karen also stated “I don’t think I’m ever gonna’ see you guys again

2:12pm – Karen Read & her father William Read arrived in the driveway of 345 Country Hill drive in North Dighton. As soon as they pulled up, the pair of them got out of Karen’s SUV & ran to check out her broken rear taillight

2:30pm (Approx) – Troopers Bukhenik & Proctor arrived in Dighton

2:31pm – Dighton police Sgt Nicholas Barros received a call from state trooper Michael Proctor requesting assistance (Read Dighton police report here) Sgt Barros informed trooper Proctor about the 911 call made by entitled William Read requesting a ride to Brockton hospital to visit his daughter Karen Read

3:00pm – Dighton police Sgt Nicholas Barros received a call from trooper Proctor informing him that he & Sgt Bukhenik were “about 10 minutes away” from William & Janet Read’s house

**Karen Read retained the services of lawyer David Yannetti sometime before state troopers Yuriy Bukhenik & Michael Proctor arrived at her parents house in Dighton at around 3:30pm**

Read the rest of Karl Dugal’s statement below;

Tap on the button below to read and interact with the Updated Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: Deluded Flying Monkey Ashley Bell & Her Harassment Of A Trial Witness

On the 29th March 2024 Aidan Kearney wrote and published a story about Ashley Bell, under the part header Canton Cover-Up Part 319.

Apparently Ashley Bell is from Bristol county, Massachusetts.

Aidan Kearney stated;

On Tuesday a woman in Bristol County reported to Turtleboy Daily News that her ex-boyfriend was visited at her former residence by MSP Detectives Yuri Bukhenik and Brian Tully, inquiring about her whereabouts.

They apparently want to ask her some questions about this text message she sent Colin Albert in July:

Screenshot

Tuesday would have presumably meant the 26th of March 2024?

Then on the 18th of April 2024, under the header Canton Coverup Part 334:Defense Witness List Features Many Names That Indicate Bombshells Are Coming At Trial, Aidan Kearney alleged the following of Ashley Bell;

Ashley was not a witness to anything, but she was visited and harassed by MSP detectives Yuri Bukhenik and Brian Tully at her home.

They also asked to look at her surveillance video footage, despite not being on the path that Karen Read would’ve taken to get home from 34 Fairview Road.

Natalie Berschneider-Wiweke referred to an Amy Ashley Bell when she was interviewed by state police on the 17th of October 2023.

Natalie stated to Massachusetts state police;

Erm Amy Ashley Bell sent erm

Aidan erm

A text

With pictures of Yuriy on her Ring camera

And erm then

Aidan sent me a screenshot where he sent that to Yannetti

And I sent that to you

So stuff like that

Listen to Natalie speaking to Massachusetts state police in the video below;

Tap on the button below to read and interact with the Updated Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: Who Was Lying, Aidan #Turtleboy Kearney, Lawyer David Yannetti Or Private Investigator Steve Scanlon?

On the 6th of September 2023 Aidan Kearney wrote and published a story headed (in part) Canton Cover-Up Part 133.

He referred to “private investigator” Steve Scanlon, previously of Scanlon Investigations Group (SIG) (Who’s website no longer appears to be available – See here)

Excerpts from Aidan Kearney’s story read;

I spoke with Scanlon in June after his name kept getting brought up by tipsters who said he knew a lot about what happened inside 34 Fairview Road. He told me that on February 3, 2022, he contacted Attorney David Yannetti after seeing Karen Read being arraigned on the news, to tell Yannetti that he believed that John O’Keefe was beaten inside that house.

Aidan Kearney also stated;

But Scanlon’s February 3 trip to David Yannetti’s office was the first turning point in this story, and will be a major part of the way this story is retold when it finally comes to an end.

Just 9 days after Aidan Kearney published his story, lawyer David Yannetti stated during a court hearing that he was contacted by Steve Scanlon on the 2nd of February 2022.

David Yannetti stated;

A friend and colleague of Brian Albert’s called me on February 2nd 2022, only hours after my client was arraigned and named Brian Albert and his nephew Colin Albert as potential suspects

So what date was it, the 2nd or the 3rd of February and who was lying, Aidan Kearney or lawyer David Yannetti?

Listen to David Yannetti below;


Tap on the button below to read more;

Tap on the button below to read and interact with the Updated Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: What Are Superfans Jon & Leigh Ann Silveira Saying Now They Know They’ve Been Duped About Trooper Proctor?

On the 18th of May 2024 Pilar Melendez wrote a story for The Daily Beast here headed This Accused Murderer Has Superfans Bankrolling Her Defense.

Jon Silveira was one of the Superfans referred to in the story and is apparently an admin for a Facebook group for killer Karen Read.

Also according to the story, Jon Silveira “is the only member who knew Read before the trial”.

He had also briefly met John O’Keefe.

Pilar Melendez stated;

Since the trial began on April 30, he has been flying up from Florida three days a week to be in the courthouse.

Interestingly Jon Silveira is quoted as stating;

It has brought out a handful of crazies, but they just go against the grain and try to start drama.

Previously, Jon Silveira falsely accused trooper Proctor of “hunting for Karen that morning bright and early”, as is evidenced in the screenshot of a Facebook post below;

Trooper Proctor didn’t arrive at the Canton police department until around 10:00am on the 29th of January 2022 – that can hardly be described as “early”.

Jon Silveira also falsely accused trooper Proctor of “tampering with evidence


The only person who tampered with evidence was Karen Read!

In September 2023 Jon Silveira and his sister Leigh Ann attended a hearing for Karen Read.

Both of them were caught on camera laughing when prosecutor Adam Lally stated that trooper Michael Proctor didn’t have a “close connection” to the home owners of 34 Fairview.

Now that evidence has come to light which demonstrates this to be true, what are Jon and Leigh Ann Silveira’s thoughts on having been lied to about this?

Watch Jon and Leigh Ann Silveira in the video clip below;

Tap on the button below to read and interact with the Updated Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: Where Is The Wife Of Brother Nathan Read & Why Hasn’t She Seemingly Attended Her Sister-In-Laws Murder Trial?

On the morning of the 29th of January 2022, Kaitlin Boudreau Read was caught on Ring camera in the driveway of 1 Meadows avenue.

Kaitlin can be seen inspecting the broken right rear taillight of her sister-in-laws SUV.

Watch Kaitlin Boudreau Read and her husband Nathan Read, Karen’s brother, and their suspicious behaviour below;

Karen Read was arrested on the 1st of February 2022 and appeared in Stoughton district court the following day.

She was released from custody at around 11:30am on $50,000 bail and was seen leaving the court with her father William Read and sister-in-law Kaitlin.

Watch video clips below;

Kaitlin Boudreau Read only appears to have attended one (or possibly two?) of Karen Read’s pre-trial hearings and she had been absent from her sister-in-laws trial. Why?

Nathan Read (Left) caught on camera on the steps of Norfolk superior court in Dedham,MA screaming at Paul O’Keefe, younger brother of victim John O’Keefe

Tap on the button below to read the Updated Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: Brother Nathan Read & His Best Friend Adam Goldstein & That Broken Taillight

On the 23rd of April 2024 Adam Goldstein made the following false statement on Facebook;

Screenshot

Adam Goldstein can be seen in the video clip below, sitting next to Aidan Kearney;

In response to Adam’s statement, Nathan and Karen Read’s cousin Kelly Read made the following statement;

Screenshot

Maybe Adam Goldstein, or Kelly Read, will know why Nathan Read didn’t clean the snow off of his sister Karen Read’s broken right rear taillight, on the 29th of January 2022?

As per video below;

And maybe Adam Goldsmith (or Kelly Read) can also explain why his best friend Nathan Read and his wife Kaitlin, looked so suspicious that day?

Watch con-artist and killer Karen Read below;

Tap on the button below to read the Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: Breaking Down More Bare Faced Lies & Spin Spread By Innocence Fraudster Aidan #Turtleboy Kearney On The Killers Orchestrated 6:03am Voicemail

On the 28th of November 2023 Aidan #Turtleboy Kearney published a blog under the partial header Canton Cover-Up Part 227.

The following is an excerpt, and yet more bare faced lies, from #Turtleboy and his blog;

When Read saw O’Keefe’s body she instinctively jumped out of the backseat, leaving her cell phone in the car, which was in the middle of calling O’Keefe’s phone.

Karen Read’s Cell Phone Was OUTSIDE

Karen Read did NOT leave her cell phone in Kerry Roberts’ car and it was NOT “in the middle of calling” John O’Keefe’s cell phone!

When Karen Read got out of Kerry Roberts car, and before Karen ran over to John O’Keefe’s body, she placed her cell phone on the ground, near to the back left hand wheel of Kerry’s car, knowing John’s voicemail had already begun recording her orchestrated performance.

Aidan Kearney also went on to publish the following intentional bare faced lies;

Eventually it reached John’s voicemail and left a 4 minute, 5 second audio message that picked up McCabe’s 911 call from inside the vehicle, and Read’s screams from outside.

Jennifer McCabe was outside when she made the 6:03:47am 911 call (which lasted 3 minutes and 32 seconds) and Karen Read’s cell phone recorded Karen scream “Kerry, Kerry”, while it was on the ground outside, a few feet away.

Again, Karen Read got out of Kerry Roberts car and placed her cell phone on the ground (where she would go back and pick it up a few minutes later) before she ran over to John O’Keefe, screaming Kerry Roberts’ name.

The reason parts of Jennifer McCabe’s 911 call were picked up on John O’Keefe’s voicemail as clear as they were, was because Jennifer had run back to Kerry Roberts car, looking for the blankets Kerry had told her were in the back.

So when Jennifer McCabe can be heard saying “Where are the blankets, I don’t see blankets Kerry“, she was standing almost directly over Karen Read’s cell phone, which was laying close by on the ground, on the snow.

And the reason the dull thud of the windscreen wipers can be heard reverberating during the voicemail recording, is because Kerry Roberts’ trunk door of her car was lifted wide open, which created a sort of echo chamber.

Karen Read can be seen picking her cell phone up off the ground at around 6:11:25am in the dashcam footage below;

Tap on the buttons below to read more;

Dynamic, Chronological Interactive TIMELINE;

Why Has Richard (Rich) Green From United States Forensics Omitted So Much In His EXHIBIT 6 On Killer Karen Read?

Richard Green, who calls himself a “data forensics expert” with United States Forensics, submitted an affidavit in support of Karen Read in April 2023.

Below is a copy of Richard Green’s EXHIBIT 6 from his 2023 affidavit relating to Karen Read’s IPhoneXS data from the 29th January 2022;

Screenshot of Richard Green’s Exhibit 6

EXHIBIT 6 can be found on page 20, by tapping on the button below;

Where Is Karen Read’s 5am “On The Dot” Call?

There are calls missing from Richard Green’s EXHIBIT 6!

Karen Read first called Kerry Roberts at around 4:58am, Kerry didn’t hear this call.

Karen Read called Kerry Roberts again at 5:00amon the dot” and said “John’s dead – Kerry Kerry Kerry” then hung up.

Did Karen Read delete these calls from her phone history?

Listen to Kerry Roberts below;

Where Are Katherine Camerano’s Calls?

Karen Read called Katherine Camerano at 4:45am.

Katherine Camerano called Karen Read at 5:00am, 5:32am, 5:34am and at 6:44am.

Were these calls also deleted by Karen Read?

Listen to Katherine Camerano in the two videos below;

Where Is Karen Read’s Call To Her Mother Janet?

Karen Read was caught on dashcam footage leaving her crime scene in Kerry Roberts’ SUV at around 6:37am.

Watch at around the 6 minute 30 second mark in the video below;

Around this time Karen Read spoke to her mother Janet Read.

Kerry Roberts evidence was that Janet Read had then said to Kerry “Please make sure she does not have her purse, she has medication in her purse I don’t want her to take”.

Why has Richard Green omitted this call from his EXHIBIT 6?

Listen to Kerry Roberts in the video below;

Where Is Erin O’Keefe’s Call?

Then at around 6:45am, while Kerry Roberts was sitting in her car outside of 34 Fairview with Karen Read, Erin O’Keefe called Karen.

Karen told Erin “John’s dead”, subsequently Kerry took the phone and told Erin “no he’s not, he’s at the hospital, they’re working on him”.

Listen to Erin O’Keefe in the two videos below;

Why Has Richard Green Omitted These Calls?

Where are all the calls and why aren’t they included in Richard Green’s EXHIBIT 6?

How many phones did Karen Read have with her on the 29th of January 2022 and what other calls are missing from Richard Green’s EXHIBIT 6?

Karen Read’s 6:03am Call To John O’Keefe’s Voicemail

Karen Read also called John O’Keefe’s phone at around 6:03am, around the same time she pretended to see his body hidden in the dark corner, under the snow.

This call went to John O’Keefe’s voicemail.

When Karen Read got out of Kerry Roberts car, Karen put her phone on the ground near the back of Kerry’s SUV.

John O’Keefe’s voicemail picked up bits of Jennifer McCabe’s 911 call and Karen Read’s performance at her crime scene.

Listen to the voicemail below;

Why was this call also not included in Richard Green’s EXHIBIT 6?

Karen Read picked her phone up at around 6:11am, as can be seen in the video below;

David Yannetti, Karen Read’s lawyer stated on 2nd February 2022, during an arraignment hearing, that his client ”was placing probably about 10 calls” to John O’Keefe’s cell phone (Listen to David Yannetti here)

Why has Richard Green only listed 8 calls from Karen Read’s phone?

Lieutenant Brian Tully confirmed Karen Read made 53 calls to John O’Keefe’s cellphone between 12:33am to 6:03am on the 29th of January 2022.

He also confirmed Karen Read called her parents preceding the calls to Jennifer McCabe and Kerry Roberts.

Tap on the button below to read and interact with the Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;

Killer Karen Read: What Were The 15 Events Caught On Ring Camera Footage?

From 6:00pm on the 28th of January 2022 through to 6:00am on the 29th of January 2022, the Ring camera App data belonging to John O’Keefe showed approximately 15 events between the 2 cameras at his residence.

The following is a list of 9 possible Ring events;

  • Possible Event #1 – 6:00pm (Approx) Michael Camerano arrived at 1 Meadows avenue with his daughter, who stayed with John O’Keefe’s niece until around 11:00pm, when Michael went back to collect her. It’s possible Michael arrived before 6pm, as he had stated in a text message “I probably won’t get to your house til 5-5.30
  • Possible Event #2 – 7:20pm (Approx) John O’Keefe & Michael Camerano left for CF McCarthy’s, moving John’s car in the driveway beforehand
  • Possible Event #3 – (At sometime) Karen Read possibly arrived at 1 Meadows avenue
  • Possible Event #4 – (At sometime) Karen Read possibly left 1 Meadows avenue for CF McCarthy’s
  • Possible Event #5 – 11:00pm (Approx) – Michael Camerano & his son, collected his daughter from 1 Meadows avenue
  • Possible Event #6 – 5:08am (Approx) Karen Read left 1 Meadows avenue 
  • Possible Event #7 – 5:48am (Approx) Karen Read, Kerry Roberts & Jennifer McCabe arrived
  • Possible Event #8 – 5:52am (Approx) Karen Read, Kerry Roberts & Jennifer McCabe Left
  • Possible Event #9 – 6:00am (Approx) Michael Camerano collected John O’Keefe’s niece. It’s possible Michael did not arrive until after 6am

Michael Camerano indicated to John O’Keefe in a text message that he would be over by around 5pm to 5:30pm on the 28th of January 2022 (Listen to Michael here), therefore Event #1 may not be relevant.

And if Michael Camerano collected John O’Keefe’s niece after 6:00am on the 29th of January, which is extremely possible, then Event #9 would also be irrelevant.

No one appears to have detailed where Karen Read was before she headed to CF McCarthy’s pub?

So if for example, she had gone to the pub straight after work, Events #6 and #7 would also not be relevant.

What were these 15 events?

Screenshot

John O’Keefe was captured on CCTV in CF McCarthy’s looking at his phone at around 8:30pm..

Had he just had an alert from his Ring camera/s?

And what was relevant about the events between 1:00am and 5:00am that were seemingly deleted?

Listen to Sgt Yuriy Bukhenik below;

Watch CCTV footage of inside CF McCarthy’s showing John O’Keefe looking at his phone below;

Tap on the button below to read the Dynamic, Chronological, Interactive TIMELINE;